Brightly Shining - Ingvild H. Rishøi - ★★★.¾

AUTHOR: Ingvild H. Rishøi

TRANSLATOR: Caroline Waight

GENRE: Literary Fiction

PUBLICATION DATE: November 19, 2024

RATING: 3.75 stars.

In a Nutshell: A Scandinavian literary fiction with a different kind of Christmas story, somewhat inspired by ‘The Little Match Girl.’ Don’t trust that joyous cover and the title; the story is dark and emotional. The ending is left open to interpretation, which might go either way for readers. Not for those looking for feel-good Christmas tales.

Plot Preview:

Tøyen, Norway. Ten-year-old Ronja is a dreamer. But she is also practical. Her alcoholic father is out of work again, so when Ronja gets to know about a job at the local Christmas tree stand, she pushes him to get it. For a few days, things are “brightly shining” for Ronja and her elder sister Melissa. But then, her father falls back to his old ways and loses the job, after having taken a huge advance on his salary. Melissa decides to take his place so that the motherless siblings aren’t sent to foster care. Ronja does her best to chip in. But can Christmas turn around so easily for the siblings?

The story comes to us in Ronja’s first-person perspective.

This debut novel was first published in Norwegian as ‘Stargate: en julefortelling’ (Stargate: A Christmas Story’). A huge success, it was instantly acclaimed as a modern classic. This version, translated to English by Caroline Waight, was released in November 2024.

Seeing that gorgeous Christmas tree and the sparkly star on the cover, and the title proudly proclaiming “Brightly Shining”, it is easy to understand why most English-language readers would take this to be a merry story for the joyful season. The truth is exactly the opposite. The title might remind you of all things bright and beautiful, but let’s not forget that even when eyes are filled with unshed tears, they look “brightly shining”. This is not a happy story in any way, though there are some heartwarming moments. I think that the title and the cover of the English edition neither indicate nor suit the content well.

Ronja, whose name means ‘star’, is a fascinating character to have as the narrator. She loves to go into dreamland, either pondering over the happy moments of the past or making wishful plans for the future. At the same time, she is mature because of her circumstances, and isn’t a typical head-in-the-clouds child we often see in light fiction. As our narrator is so young, we need to be prepared for a lot of reading between the lines. Ronja tells us what she knows and wishes and wonders, but she can’t tell us facts beyond her limited worldview. As such, the character development of the other characters is a bit surface-level. But what little we see is enough to get a handle on them.

Ronja’s elder sister Melissa is excellent. Forced to be a provider and caretaker to Ronja at the young age of sixteen, Melissa comes across as a mature youngster who is worried about the future but isn’t so fearful as to run away from it. I simply loved the realistic bond between the two siblings. There are also a few amazing secondary characters in the book, my favourite being the caretaker.

The blurb doesn’t mention this, but Hans Christian Andersen’s ‘The Little Match Girl’ has a strong role to play in the story, both through direct mentions in the plot as well as some scenes inspired by the sad fairy tale. If you know this story, then you can be prepared for a similar melancholic vibe in this novella.

The Scandinavian setting is used beautifully in the plot. The snow, the trees, the people, the atmosphere – all seem so real that you will feel as chilled as Ronja does in the Christmas tree stand. The portrayal of the family is also true to life, especially in the depiction of their father’s alcoholism (which is disappointing as well as infuriating) and the girls’ regular struggles to find enough food.

At just 192 pages (that too, in the hardcover edition), this is a quick read despite being literary in style. There are no chapter divisions, but there are sectional breaks in between scene transitions.

Ronja’s age might lull you into thinking that this book can work for middle-graders or teens, but be warned: the content is not for children. This is literary fiction, not middle-grade or YA fiction. There are many upsetting scenarios that are suitable only for adult eyes. The book does contain Christmassy feelings, but not necessarily of the warm or faith-oriented kind. The focus in the book is more on the capitalist nature of contemporary Christmas celebrations, with everyone having forgotten the true reason for the season.

In some ways, the book reminded me of Claire Keegan’s ‘Small Things Like These’, which is also an unusual Advent-Christmas story. But while Keegan’s novella, though equally grim, ends with a ray of hope, this book moves towards an array of confusion. You see, the ending is open to interpretation. There seems to be a sudden jump in genre, which I simply couldn’t understand the reason for. I am still trying to decide if what happened was literal or metaphorical. The final scene could be considered either magic or tragic, depending on your perspective.

One thing I simply didn’t like in the book was the repetitive use of a blasphemous cuss word. There might be people in real life who say such things, but does a Christmas story need to have a cuss word referencing ‘Jesus’ in such a vulgar way? This could have easily been avoided.

All in all, this is a story set during Christmas, but it is not a Christmas story. Mostly well-written but character-oriented, it will work better for literary fiction lovers looking for a somewhat serious holiday read. This book is being adapted for film. I hope the movie will shed more light on the ending because I do want to know what exactly happened.

Recommended to those who appreciate darker fairy tales/ Christmas stories such as ‘The Little Match Girl’ and don’t mind the cuss words. It is definitely not for those looking for a uplifting festive tale with a happy ending.

3.75 stars. (I’d have gone higher if the ending had been clearer and the language, cleaner.)

My thanks to Grove Atlantic for providing the DRC of “Brightly Shining” via NetGalley. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.